top of page

Child Trafficking Disguised as Adoption

Child trafficking disguised as adoption is a serious and unethical practice where children are forcibly or fraudulently taken from their families or communities under the guise of adoption. This can involve various forms of deception, including convincing birth parents to give up their children without fully understanding the consequences, or even the outright abduction of children. Traffickers exploit the adoption process for profit, sometimes arranging "adoptions" that involve illegal or unethical transactions, where the welfare of the child is entirely disregarded.

This form of exploitation often takes place in regions with weak legal frameworks or where adoption practices are not transparent, making it easier for traffickers to manipulate the system. International adoption, especially, can be a high-risk area for child trafficking, as vulnerable families may be coerced or deceived into giving up their children in exchange for promises of a better life.

​

Key Considerations:

​

  • The Role of Unethical Agencies: Some adoption agencies, in pursuit of profit, may facilitate or turn a blind eye to child trafficking disguised as adoption. These agencies may falsify documents, manipulate birth parents, or ignore warning signs of trafficking.

​

  • The Impact on Children: Trafficked children may be placed in abusive or exploitative environments, with no legal protections or the opportunity to know their true origins. The trauma of being trafficked can have long-term emotional, physical, and psychological consequences.

​

  • The Need for Strict Oversight: Stronger regulations, monitoring, and enforcement are necessary to prevent child trafficking under the pretense of adoption. Ethical adoption agencies and international bodies must work together to ensure transparency and accountability in the process.

 

Organizations Fighting Child Trafficking (General):

​

  • Destiny Rescue: This organization focuses on rescuing children from sex trafficking and exploitation. Their website details their rescue operations and provides information on the realities of child trafficking.

  • International Justice Mission (IJM): IJM works to combat human trafficking through policy change, training local law enforcement, and direct intervention to rescue victims.

  • The Exodus Road: This organization trains local operatives to identify trafficking victims and supports law enforcement in rescue operations.

  • Walk Free: This international human rights group focuses on eradicating modern slavery, including child trafficking. Their website includes research and reports on the issue, including the connection between orphanages and trafficking.

​

Resources Discussing the Risks of Adoption and Child Trafficking:

​

  • UNICEF: The United Nations Children's Fund has published reports examining the risks of intercountry adoption and its similarities to child trafficking.

  • The Hague Convention on the Protection of Children and Co-operation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption: This international agreement aims to establish safeguards to ensure that intercountry adoptions are in the best interests of the child and to prevent the abduction, sale, or trafficking of children. Information about the convention and related documents can be found on the website of the Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH).  

  • Academic Articles and Reports: Websites like ResearchGate and university repositories may host scholarly articles discussing the complexities of intercountry adoption and its potential links to child trafficking. Search for terms like "intercountry adoption as child trafficking," "illegal adoption," and "manufactured orphans." One example found in the search results is "MANUFACTURED ORPHANS: A Call for Recognition of Illegal Adoption as Child Trafficking" published in the Himachal Pradesh National Law University Law Journal.

​

Advocacy and Education Opportunity: Raising awareness about the dangers of child trafficking in adoption systems can help individuals and organizations better identify red flags. Advocates can call for stronger laws and more transparency in international adoption processes to ensure children are not exploited.

Child Trafficking

​Open vs. Closed Adoption

Open adoption refers to an adoption arrangement where the birth parents and adoptive parents maintain some form of ongoing contact. This can include the exchange of letters, pictures, phone calls, or even face-to-face meetings, depending on the agreement between the birth parents and adoptive family. In an open adoption, the adoptee has more access to information about their birth family, which can help them form a more cohesive sense of identity as they grow older.

​

Closed adoption, on the other hand, involves no direct contact or communication between the birth parents and the adoptive family after the adoption is finalized. In closed adoptions, identifying information (names, addresses, etc.) about both the birth parents and the adoptive family is kept confidential. Historically, closed adoption was the standard practice, but there has been a growing preference for open adoption as people recognize the benefits it can offer in terms of the adoptee's identity and sense of belonging.​

​

  • Benefits of Open Adoption: Open adoption can help adoptees understand their background, build a connection with their birth family, and feel a stronger sense of identity. It also can offer birth parents peace of mind, knowing their child is in a loving home.

​

  • Challenges of Open Adoption: There can be emotional difficulties for both birth parents and adoptive parents, such as navigating boundaries, adjusting to new relationships, or coping with unresolved grief. It's important to clearly define expectations and maintain respectful communication.

 

Where can I find resources about this topic?

​

1. Hague Convention on Intercountry Adoption Information:

​

  • Official Government Websites (e.g., U.S. Department of State): Look for sections on intercountry adoption. These often explain the framework provided by the Hague Convention, which emphasizes the best interests of the child and the need for ethical practices. While not solely focused on open vs. closed adoption, they provide context on the legal and ethical considerations involved in international adoptions, which can influence the possibilities for openness. For example, the U.S. Department of State's website has a section on Intercountry Adoption.

​

  • The Hague Conference on Private International Law: This is the body that developed the Hague Convention. Their website may have information about the principles underlying international adoption.

​

2. Reputable Adoption Agencies with International Programs:

​

  • Hague-Accredited Agencies: Agencies accredited under the Hague Convention are generally considered reliable as they adhere to specific ethical and legal standards. Many agency websites have comprehensive information about their international adoption programs, and some may discuss the possibilities for different levels of openness depending on the country and the birth parents' wishes. Examples include Nightlight Christian Adoptions and An Open Door Adoption Agency.

  • Agencies Focused on Specific Countries: If you are interested in adopting from a particular country, look for agencies specializing in that region. They will have the most up-to-date information on the adoption laws and practices of that country, including the typical levels of openness in international adoptions.

​

3. Adoption Support and Advocacy Organizations:

​

  • General Adoption Information Websites (with sections on international adoption): Websites like Adoption.org or Considering Adoption often have sections dedicated to international adoption that may touch upon the topic of open vs. closed adoption in a global context.

  • Organizations Focused on Adoptee Rights and Welfare: These organizations may offer perspectives on the importance of knowing one's origins and the potential impacts of closed adoptions, even in international contexts.

​

Key Considerations:

​

  • Varying Laws and Practices: The laws and cultural norms surrounding adoption, and specifically open adoption, differ significantly from country to country. What might be possible or common in one nation may be restricted or unheard of in another.

  • Birth Parent Rights and Preferences: In international adoption, the rights and wishes of the birth parents in the child's country of origin are paramount. Their willingness for openness will heavily influence the type of adoption.

  • The Role of Adoption Agencies: Agencies facilitate international adoptions and act as intermediaries. They can provide guidance on the possibilities for open adoption based on the specific country and circumstances.

  • Post-Adoption Contact Agreements: If an open adoption is arranged internationally, the enforceability and nature of post-adoption contact agreements can vary greatly depending on the legal systems involved.

  • Shifting Trends: Globally, there is a growing recognition of the benefits of openness in adoption for all parties involved, particularly the child. However, closed adoptions still occur in international contexts.

  • Ethical Considerations: Ensuring that any level of openness is ethical, respects the privacy and wishes of all parties, and prioritizes the child's well-being is crucial in international adoption.

​

Advocacy and Education Opportunity: Advocating for open adoption is one way to promote more ethical adoption practices. Education on the benefits of open adoption and encouraging agencies to support it can help change perceptions and create healthier adoption environments. 

Open vs Closed Adoption

Transparency in Adoption Practices

Transparency in adoption practices refers to the openness and honesty of the adoption process. This includes clear communication with birth parents, adoptive parents, and children about the process, legal rights, medical histories, and expectations. Transparency ensures that everyone involved in the adoption is informed, and that no one is coerced or misled into making decisions they don’t fully understand.

​

Unfortunately, there have been instances where adoption agencies and facilitators have hidden crucial information from birth parents or adoptive parents, leading to exploitation or unethical practices. This includes not disclosing potential risks, misleading birth parents about their rights, or covering up the true nature of an adoption situation.

​

Key Considerations:

​

  • Clear Legal Processes: Ethical adoption agencies must provide detailed and comprehensible legal documentation to all parties involved, explaining the rights of birth parents, the responsibilities of adoptive parents, and the legal implications of adoption.

​

  • Birth Parent Rights: Birth parents must be fully informed about their rights, including whether the adoption is open or closed, their ability to withdraw consent, and how they can stay involved in their child’s life post-adoption (in open adoption scenarios).

​

  • Adoptee Rights to Information: Adoptees should have the right to access information about their birth families when they are older, and they should be given opportunities to connect with their roots if they choose.

​

Where can I learn more about this?

​

1. Adoption Agencies and Organizations Emphasizing Ethical Practices:

​

  • Look for adoption agencies that explicitly state their commitment to ethical and transparent practices. Their websites often detail their processes, fees, and the rights of all parties involved (adoptive parents, birth parents, and adoptees).

    • Example: Agencies that highlight providing clear information about the adoption process, offering support and counseling to birth parents, and facilitating open communication when appropriate.

​

  • Websites of organizations focused on ethical adoption practices can offer valuable insights.

    • Example: The Coalition for Truth and Transparency in Adoption (adoptiontruthandtransparency.org) advocates for openness and provides resources related to adoption policies and laws.

    • Example: AdoptChange (blog.adoptchange.org) focuses on reshaping private domestic adoption practices through education, advocacy, and increased transparency.

​

2. Legal and Governmental Resources:

​

  • Government websites related to child welfare and adoption in your specific country or region will provide information on the legal frameworks governing adoption, which often include aspects of transparency (e.g., regulations around information sharing, consent processes).

  • International conventions and agreements related to adoption, such as the Hague Convention on the Protection of Children and Co-operation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption, aim to ensure legality and prevent unethical practices in international adoptions. Information about these can often be found on the websites of organizations like the Hague Conference on Private International Law (hcch.net).

​

3. Advocacy and Support Groups:

​

  • Websites of adoptee rights organizations and support groups often share information about the importance of transparency and access to information for adoptees. They may also provide resources on navigating closed adoptions and advocating for more openness.

  • Organizations supporting birth parents can also offer information on their rights and the level of transparency they can expect in the adoption process.

​

4. Academic and Research Institutions:

​

  • University research centers or organizations focused on family studies may publish reports and articles on various aspects of adoption, including transparency. While these might be more academic, they can offer in-depth analysis and reliable data.

    • Example: Look for research from centers focusing on gender and diversity or child welfare.

​

​Advocacy and Education Opportunity: Advocating for transparent adoption systems ensures that all parties are empowered and protected. Calls for laws that require open records and full disclosure during the adoption process can help reduce the possibility of coercion or abuse.

Transparency

The Rights of Birth Families

The rights of birth families are often overshadowed in the adoption process, but birth parents have significant rights that must be respected for an adoption to be ethical. Birth parents, especially mothers, should be provided with all necessary information to make an informed decision about adoption. They also have the right to consent or withdraw consent for the adoption, and their voices should be heard and respected.

​

Rights and Considerations for Birth Families in Adoption (General Principles):

​

  • The Right to Information and Counseling: In many places, birth parents have the right to receive information about adoption as an option, along with other choices like parenting or temporary care. They may also be entitled to counseling services to help them make informed decisions. For example, adoption agencies often provide counseling to expectant parents to discuss their options and the implications of each choice.

​

  • The Right to Consent: Generally, the voluntary and informed consent of the birth parents (or legal guardians) is a crucial aspect of legal adoption. This means they should understand the implications of relinquishing their parental rights and agree to it without coercion. The specifics of when and how this consent can be given (e.g., before or after birth, in front of a legal authority) vary greatly. Some jurisdictions may have a period after signing consent during which it can be revoked.

​

  • The Right to Choose the Adoptive Family (in some cases): In some adoption models, particularly in private or independent adoptions, birth parents may have the opportunity to be involved in selecting the adoptive family for their child. This can range from reviewing profiles to meeting prospective adoptive parents. This is more common in open or semi-open adoption arrangements.

​

  • The Right to an Open or Closed Adoption: Birth parents often have the right to choose the level of contact they wish to have with the child and the adoptive family after the adoption.

    • Open Adoption: Involves some level of ongoing communication or contact between the birth family and the adoptive family, which can range from exchanging letters and photos to arranging visits.

    • Closed Adoption: Traditionally involves no contact between the birth family and the adoptive family after the adoption is finalized. However, even in closed adoptions, there might be options for future contact if all parties agree (e.g., through a mutual consent registry).

    • Semi-Open Adoption: May involve indirect contact facilitated by an intermediary, such as an adoption agency.

​

  • Rights Regarding the Child's Heritage: Some legal and ethical guidelines emphasize the importance of preserving the child's cultural, ethnic, and religious heritage. While the adoptive parents become the legal parents, there may be considerations to ensure the child has some connection to their roots, if appropriate and in the child's best interest.

​

  • Legal Representation: In many jurisdictions, birth parents have the right to their own legal counsel during the adoption process, often provided at no cost to them. This ensures they understand their rights and the legal implications of the adoption.

​

  • Financial Assistance: In some cases, adoptive parents or adoption agencies may provide financial assistance to the birth mother for pregnancy-related expenses, as permitted by law. However, it's crucial that such assistance is not seen as coercion for the adoption.

​

  • Post-Adoption Contact Agreements: In some jurisdictions, legally binding agreements for post-adoption contact can be established between birth families and adoptive families. These agreements outline the terms of ongoing communication or visits.

​

  • Mutual Consent Registries: Many regions have voluntary registries where adopted individuals and their birth relatives can register their contact information. If there is a mutual match, contact can be facilitated. These registries typically operate when the adopted person reaches adulthood.

​

  • Access to Information (for the adopted person in the future): While not a direct right of the birth family, it's relevant to note that adopted individuals often have the right to access information about their birth history when they reach a certain age (usually 18), depending on the laws of the specific region. This may include non-identifying information or, in some cases, identifying information about their birth parents.

​

Important Considerations:

​

  • "Best Interests of the Child": Across international adoption principles, the paramount consideration is the "best interests of the child." This principle often guides decisions regarding birth family rights, balancing the rights of birth parents with the child's need for a stable and nurturing permanent family.

​

  • Varying Legal Frameworks: Adoption laws are highly specific to each country, and even within countries (e.g., different states or provinces), there can be significant differences. International treaties like the Hague Convention on Intercountry Adoption aim to establish safeguards for international adoptions, focusing on the child's best interests and the legality of the process, which indirectly touches upon the rights of birth families by ensuring ethical practices and preventing coercion.

​

  • Ethical Considerations: Beyond legal rights, ethical considerations play a significant role in adoption practices. Respect for the birth family's situation, their decision-making process, and their emotional well-being is crucial.

​

Where to Look for More Information (General Websites):

​

While not exhaustive and keeping in mind the need for country-specific information for concrete legal advice, the following types of organizations often provide general information about adoption principles and considerations, which can touch upon birth family rights:

​

  • International Adoption Organizations: Organizations that work on international adoption often adhere to certain ethical guidelines and may provide information about the principles they follow, which include respecting the rights of birth families. Examples include (but are not limited to - and remember I cannot recommend specific websites):

    • Organizations accredited under the Hague Convention on Intercountry Adoption.

    • International social service agencies.

​

  • Child Welfare Organizations: International organizations focused on child welfare and children's rights often have resources or policy statements that address ethical adoption practices, which include considerations for birth families. Examples include UNICEF and other UN-related bodies.

​

  • Academic Institutions and Research Centers: Universities and research centers that study adoption may have publications or summaries of international adoption trends and principles, which can touch upon the rights of birth families.

​

  • Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) focused on Adoption: Many NGOs work to advocate for ethical adoption practices and may provide general information about the rights and needs of all parties involved, including birth families.

​

To get reliable and specific information, it is crucial to consult legal professionals and adoption agencies in the specific country or region relevant to the adoption. General websites can provide a broad understanding of the issues, but legal rights are always defined and protected by the laws of a particular jurisdiction.

Rights of Birth Family

Ethical Adoption Agencies

Ethical adoption agencies are those that prioritize the well-being of the child, respect the rights of birth families, and support the adoptive families throughout the process. These agencies operate with full transparency, ensuring that all parties are informed and respected. They uphold high ethical standards, such as not pressuring birth parents into giving up their child and ensuring that adoption is in the child's best interests.

​

Key Considerations:

​

  • Non-Exploitative: Ethical agencies do not take advantage of vulnerable birth parents. They provide a supportive environment where birth parents can make their decision without pressure and with full knowledge of their options.

​

  • Comprehensive Support: Ethical agencies provide comprehensive support to both birth parents and adoptive parents, including counseling, educational resources, and post-adoption services. They work to create a system that is holistic and responsive to the needs of all parties.

​

  • Adoption Fees: Ethical agencies are transparent about adoption fees, ensuring that the costs involved are reasonable, transparent, and used appropriately. They should not charge exorbitant fees or engage in practices that exploit financial vulnerabilities.

​

When researching adoption agencies, consider the following:

​

  • Review their website thoroughly: Look for information about their mission, values, services, fees, and approach to ethical practices.

  • Ask for references: Speak with adoptive families and, if possible, birth parents who have worked with the agency.

  • Inquire about their Hague accreditation if you are considering international adoption.

  • Ask detailed questions about their policies and procedures regarding birth parent rights, counseling, screening of adoptive families, and post-adoption support.

  • Be wary of agencies that seem to pressure expectant parents or offer excessive financial incentives beyond legally permissible expenses.

  • Ensure they facilitate independent legal counsel for birth parents.

​

​By carefully researching and evaluating adoption agencies based on these ethical considerations, you can increase your chances of working with an organization that prioritizes the well-being of everyone involved in the adoption process.

Ethical Agency
bottom of page